NEW YORK, 19 AUGUST 2009
Dear EarthTalk: As I understand it, "clean" coal really isn't - yet the
Bush Administration gushed strongly for it. What is Obama's take on it?
John Zippert, Eutaw, AL
Barack Obama and George W. Bush differ in many ways, but both have
embraced so-called "clean coal" for providing an ongoing supply of cheap
and readily available energy for electricity generation.
The term "clean coal" is loosely defined as coal that is washed or
processed to remove pollutants, so as to reduce emissions of carbon
dioxide (CO2), the leading greenhouse gas, when the coal is burned.
Coal-burning plants emit 40 percent of U.S. CO2 pollution - half of our
electricity comes from coal - so reducing the industry's carbon footprint
in any way possible would be a big win for the environment.
Luckily for clean coal advocates, the White House has been and
continues to push for its development. George W. Bush's support for clean
coal dates back to his first term in office, when he stated that such
technologies should be encouraged as a means of reducing dependence on
foreign oil. And since taking office, the Obama administration has
committed $3.4 billion in stimulus dollars to clean coal projects.
But green groups continue to question the wisdom of relying on coal at
all. Coal wreaks environmental havoc, from the coal mines that pollute
rivers and streams, to the premature deaths of coal miners from accidents
and lung diseases, to the release of greenhouse gases, mercury and other
toxins at power plants.
According to Greenpeace, burning coal emits 29 percent more CO2 than
does burning oil or natural gas. And coal-fired power plants are the
world's largest sources of atmospheric mercury, a known neurotoxin that
disperses quickly throughout the environment and into the food chain.
Greenpeace says that clean coal technologies will not address this
problem, and that there are "no commercially available technologies to
prevent mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants." Also, the group
says, clean coal will do nothing to mitigate coal mining's damage to
wildlife habitat and drinking water sources.
"There is no such thing as 'clean coal' and there never will be," Dan
Becker of the Sierra Club told the Grist.org website. "It's an oxymoron."
The Reality Coalition, a group of nonprofits that includes the Sierra
Club, has been running TV ads seeking to debunk industry claims that coal
can be clean. Green groups also worry that pushing clean coal will only
delay the transition to a truly cleaner and greener energy infrastructure
based on solar, wind and other emissions-free renewable energy sources.
In April of 2009,
environmental lawyer Robert F. Kennedy, Jr. questioned the motivations of
Obama and other politicians who back clean coal. "The coal industry and
the carbon industry in general are the largest contributors to the
political process," Kennedy told ABC News. "You don't have politicians
representing the American public, but rather the people who finance their
Of course, Obama's support for clean coal doesn't negate the fact that
he has proposed spending much more on further development of alternative
energy sources. He has called for getting 10 percent of U.S. electricity
from renewable sources by 2012 and 25 percent by 2025, and has committed
upwards of $32 billion of stimulus dollars to the cause, according to an
analysis by the nonprofit Environment America.
CONTACTS: Greenpeace, www.greenpeace.org; Reality
SEND YOUR ENVIRONMENTAL QUESTIONS TO: EarthTalk, P.O. Box 5098,
Westport, CT 06881; firstname.lastname@example.org. Read
past columns at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalk/archives.php.
EarthTalk is now a book! Details and order information at: www.emagazine.com/earthtalkbook.
Related Culturekiosque Archives
Batteries: Clean Power from Underground
Undoing George W.
Bush's Environmental Legacy
Desert Botanical Garden Hosts Glass Artist Dale Chihuly
Frontline: The Old Man and
the Storm: By June Cross
George W. Bush Stamped "Idiot King" First-Class Forever
2008: Year of the Rat, Leap Year...and Now, Year of the
Environment: Green Burials
World Water Day and the
Global Water Challenge
The Evolution of Charles Darwin's Reputation
Impact on Wildlife
Penguins to Get
Protection Under Endangered Species