
|

|
|
- Chausson's much neglected opera Le Roi
Arthus was given its first complete staging in France here in
Montpellier. How totally amazing that a work of such quality had a
posthumous premiere in 1903, four years after the composer's death,
and that in Brussels, with the Paris Opéra deigning to
present Act 3 in 1913. Three concert performances followed in the
late 40s, 50s and 80s (the last of which served as the basis for the
Erato recording which is now out of print, and that was it until
last year when the Dortmund Opera unveiled its production which was
in fact co-produced by Montpellier. The Bregenz Festival and Cologne
Opera were partners in a separate production almost simultaneously.
John Dew's production this evening was in his simple, abstract vein,
which in fact suited the work quite well. A late defection of the
soprano brought us Jane Casselman who sings Genièvre in
Dortmund, and while it is not the most beautiful sound one has ever
heard, we are grateful to her for saving the show. Marcel Vanaud in
the title role offered his puffed-up singing which too often makes
him unintelligible. Only tenor Stephen O'Mara's Lancelot emerged
relatively unscathed. All three leading roles are impossible to
cast, requiring Wagnerian voices which can also be fined down and at
the same time sing in impeccable French. Alain Vernhes' Merlin
almost stole the show in his one scene. Conductor Emmanuel Joel
could probably have used a few more rehearsals with the Orchestre
Philharmonique de Montpellier, while the combined choruses of
Montpellier and Nantes didn't quite blend. But again, confronted
with a work of such stature which has been more than neglected,
perhaps ignored is the operative word, for almost a century, we set
aside our quibbles.
|
|

|
|
- listen to the new Philips recording of Ruslan
and Lyudmila (446 746-2) which I will discuss at length when I
see the accompanying video of the production. Gergiev's fiery
conducting makes for exciting listening, but he is let down by the
basses. As this is the recording most readily available I would not
hesitate to recommend it. The packaging, however, is unhandy as
there is no separate box for the CDs and libretto which makes
shelving a problem, also the case with the new Solti Meistersinger
on Decca.
|
|

|
|
- I should have been in Montpellier for Le Roi
Arthus, but the French railroad's prolonged strike made it
impossible - only got to Montpellier towards 9 pm, so I continued on
home, arriving at 2.30 am. I was, however, able to read most of Remy
Stricker's new book about Schubert, which is fascinating,
particularly what he has to say about the operas and their
stageworthiness (Gallimard).
|
|

|
|
- What a relief to see a production of Werther
that looks like something the composer and librettist might have
recognized. Roberto Alagna's first stab at the title role offered
ample proof that he should stick to the French repertoire, his
exemplary diction enhancing our enjoyment of the work. I missed some
of the softer singing that he used to give us, but he nonetheless
got the part right, which is not easy to do. François Leroux
was Albert, a fascinating contrast after his Prince of Homburg last
month, while Brigitte Fournier was an exemplary Sophie. Béatrice
Uria-Monzon's Charlotte was more of a problem; she looks the role to
perfection, acts like a dream, but the sounds are inappropriate when
she pushes her chest register to undreamt of heights and tries to
inflate her voice beyond its natural size. Richard Armstrong's
conducting didn't seem quite comfortable but all praise to Hubert
Monloup and Nicolas Joël.
|
|

|
|
- Grieg's songs are not something I usually rush
to listen to, but a new release on Naxos (8.553781) by an unknown
soprano provided total delight. Bodil Arnesen's light voice suits
much of this repertory, offering a judicious mixture of familiar and
unknown material. Erling R. Eriksen's keyboard support is a model
and I would recommend this CD to anyone looking for an introduction
to a superb melodist. As a change of pace, Schumann by Barbara
Bonney and Vladimir Ashkenazy (Decca 452 898-2) turns out to be
disappointing. Throughout the centerpiece of the album, Frauenliebe
und -leben, the absence of portamento, the exaggerated rubato
and the very dry accompaniment become a hindrance to one's
appreciation of Schumann's anti-feminist cycle. Bonney's very light
voice, moreover, is not suited to all the songs she has chosen,
overt drama being outside her range. As has become fashionable, two
groups of Clara Schumann's songs are interspersed, with the soprano
providing a personal note in the programme defending her choice. In
fact, Clara's songs are interesting as yet another reflection of the
"romantic" movement.
|
|

|
|
- Pelléas et Mélisande,
recorded live at the Lille Opera last year by Naxos (8.660047/9), is
the best of the bargain-priced issues and rivals some of the
top-price versions as well. The only thing in its disfavor is that
it is spread over three discs in order to avoid the otherwise
necessary awkward break, but I'll take a touch of awkwardness if it
means paying for one less disc, even at Naxos prices. Jean-Claude
Casadesus has the measure of the piece, giving us a straightforward
reading which at the same time does not neglect the score's
coloring, something the Orchestre National de Lille is capable of
furnishing. What a pleasure to hear singers for whom the language is
not a problem so that they can concentrate on their roles without
worrying about errant vowel sounds. Both Gérard Théruel
Pelléas and Armand Arapian Golaud have long
experience of their roles, including a spell with the Peter
Brook-Marius Constant Impressions de Pelléas, so that
they impart a certain authority to their assumptions. Théruel,
a baritone, occasionally strains at the upper notes of his role, a
fault common to almost any baritone Pelléas. Mireille
Delunsch offers a rich-voiced Mélisande who can also fine
down her voice and give us those half-voiced utterances without
sounding totally washed out. Gabriel Bacquier has moved to the role
of Arkel, and while he may not have a true bass resonance, his
command of the role is perfect, and Hélène Jossoud's
Geneviève sounds much better on the recording than in the
theater. Françoise Golfier's Yniold is unique in the
child-like sound she produces, but with a clear focus on the text,
somehting of which a child is incapable. Bravo Naxos, and bravo to
Casadesus and his orchestra who have realized that it is better to
have a regular recording contract with a budget label such as Naxos
than a very occasional disc on some other label, particularly when
they will be recording a mix of familiar and unfamiliar French
music, something at which they excel.
|
|

|
|
- listen to Christie's new recording of Hippolyte
et Aricie (Erato 0630-15517-2), a work with which he has been
involved for over thirty years. Using the "A" cast of the
Paris Opera performances, Christie gives an incisive reading in
which the Phèdre of Lorraine Hunt and the Thésée
of Laurent Naouri are particularly outstanding. It is clear that the
entire cast had the work in their bones, to the special benefit of
the singers in the title roles who were rather wan in the theater.
Anna Maria Panzarella remains a small-scale if charming Aricie,
while the Hippolyte of Mark Padmore unfortunately sounds strained
above the staff where he often lunges wildly at notes which should
come easily in this music. The only obstacle to a nonetheless
unqualified recommendation is that Minkowski's Archiv recording of
18 months ago set a standard which has here been equalled but not
surpassed, so that we must ask if this recording was truly
necessary. Choice will ultimately boil down to the following: do you
prefer a more apt pair of lovers (Véronique Gens and
Jean-Paul Fouchécourt for Minkowski) or a more overtly
dramatic Phèdre and Thésée as on the Christie
version? Or do you have a particular preference for or allergy to
either of the conductors? One question which remains unelucidated in
the face of claims to be using the original 1735 score is the
variant readings of the lovers' scenes in Acts 2 and 4; and surely
something might have been said about using the 1742 version's Pluto
and chorus number already on the Minkowski recording.
|
|

|
|
- we combine the European Orchid Conference and
the opera, Handel's Rinaldo in the Pizzi production which
has been making the rounds since 1983. Pizzi has abdicated all
responsibility as stage director in placing the performers on
platforms which are constantly shifted around by an army of little
men, while other little men are kept busy waving the yards of
chiffon which form the cloaks of the performers. Fortunately
Jennifer Larmore in the title role succeeded on more than one
occasion in making us forget all the nonsense when she spoke
directly to the emotions of the audience. Donna Brown as the good
girl Almirena and Lillian Watson as the bad girl Armida were
formidable adversaries, while the men seemed underparted.
|
|

|
|
- listen to two new releases which will be dealt
with in an article: Demetrio e Polibio by Rossini and L'Americano
by Piccini; neither is essential but both have many points of
interest.
|
|

|
|
- more catching up, with von Otter and Holzmair.
You may question my pairing, but the fact that they have both come
up with recordings of French music from the turn of the century is
noteworthy. Von Otter and Holzmair offer one work in common, Fauré's
Bonne Chanson, but von Otter uses the later arrangement with
added string quintet, which I am not convinced adds much to the
work. Her interpretation, however, is serious, ardent and well
thought through. Other items on the disc which benefit from the
iridescence of von Otter's mezzo are the Ravel Mallarmé
settings, Chausson's "Chanson perpétuelle",
Delage's "Quatre Poèmes hindous", Saint-Saëns "Flûte
invisible". An irresistible turn is the total deadpan approach
she brings to Poulenc's Rhapsodie nègre, with an
almost unrecognizable baritone sound. Bengt Forsberg provides his
customary faultless accompaniments as do a host of instrumentalists
(DGG 447 752-2). That the Austro-German turn of the century is also
her domain is amply demonstrated by a Mahler - Zemlinsky disc with
John Eliot Gardiner conducting the NDR-Sinfonieorchester (DGG 439
928-2). Singer and conductor neatly dovetail into each other's
concepts, the close focus allowing us to hear many details, an
approach especially beneficial to Zemlinsky's Op. 13, Sechs Gesänge
nach Gedichten von Maurice Maeterlinck. I am not familiar with
the other recordings recently issued, but I find it difficult to
imagine anyone surpassing this version. Mahler's Lieder eines
fahrenden Gesellen and 5 Rückert-Lieder also
benefit from this fusion of intent. Wolfgang Holzmair's excursion
into Fauré, Duparc and Ravel (Philips 446 686-2) is
praiseworthy, but he does not seem to live the music as does von
Otter. Add to this a whitening of tone at the top and we must
consign this recording to the pile of unnecessary CDs (Philips 446
686-2). Gérard Wyss's accompaniments never lapse into the
sentimental, a danger in this music.
|
|

|
|
- start catching up on my backlog. William
Christie's new contract with Erato seems to keep him in the
recording studio much of the time. Two recent recordings are devoted
to the secular music of Marc-Antoine Charpentier, La Descente
d'Orphée aux Enfers (0630-11913-2) and Les Plaisirs
de Versailles (0630-14774-2). There is some doubt as to whether
the former has come down to us in its entirety as it ends somewhat
abruptly with the descent of Orpheus. Charpentier has come up with
music of great eloquence for Orphée, here dispatched with
elegance by tenor Paul Agnew. A new generation of singers in the
remaining roles demonstrate that there is still a great deal of
talent in the ranks. Sopranos Patricia Petibon and Sophie Daneman
especially stand out. Les Plaisirs de Versailles shows us an
unsuspected aspect of Charpentier, a sense of humor, with Music
(Sophie Daneman) disputing with Conversation (Katalin Károlyi)
as to which is more important in social life, appealing finally to
Comus (Jean-François Gardeil) to settle their quarrel. The
disc is filled out with three "Airs sur les stances du Cid"
and a "Pastoraletta", Amor vince ogni cosa, a
charming bit of fluff about two shepherdesses and two shepherds and
a lost lamb. Les Arts Florissants, small format, shows that they
have few equals in this music, while Christie's sure hand is exactly
what is needed.
|
|

|
|
- The new Collins recording of Britten's Albert
Herring (70422) will undoubtedly be bombarded with comments that
it somehow misses the atmosphere of the version conducted by the
composer. I was enchanted by this performance conducted by Steuart
Bedford, part of the Britten edition now underway with this company.
Only the Lady Billows of Josephine Barstow seems out of sorts, her
acid tones and uncertain high notes not pleasant to hear. Of her
characterization I can offer nothing but praise. Christopher Gillett
in the title role imposes his own view of the character, while
Felicity Palmer's Florence is almost visible in an exceptional
portrayal. Robert Lloyd, Peter Savidge, Susan Gritton and Stuart
Kale are the village worthies, while Della Jones as Mrs. Herring
almost makes an unsympathetic role sympathetic. Gerald Finley and
Ann Taylor as the young lovers cum conspirators sound the right age
and even the children (Yvette Bonner, Témimé Bowling
and Matthew Long) for a change are on pitch though perhaps a shade
too genteel. See Modern British Opera, Part 1, for a discussion of
other recent recordings of Britten operas.
|
|

|
|
- the Berlin Statsoper brings its new production
of Lohengrin to the Châtelet - what utter nonsense.
It's clear that Harry Kupfer has nothing to say, requiring the
assistance of not one but two dramaturges to give us a confused,
illogical staging: Gottfried and Lohengrin are projections of the
same personality and the entire evening is Elsa's dream and the
audience's nightmare. Daniel Barenboim tended to let the orchestra
have its head at climactic moments. Johan Botha in the title role
offered the kind of easy singing not heard since the heyday of
Sandor Konya, while the production which had him immobilized
throughout required nothing in the way of acting. Emily Magee's Elsa
was hard put to sustain her unbroken three and a half hours on
stage, but offered lovely singing most of the time. Falk Struckmann
ranted his way through Kurvenal, while Deborah Polaski's Ortrud
resembled Morticia Adams and sounded raw at the top. René
Pape's King offered the most solid singing after Botha. But what a
waste.
|
|

|
|
- Giulio Cesare at the Palais Garnier.
This is the kind of joky production I normally would not like, but
somehow it mostly seems to work, except when the irrepressible
Dominique Visse takes over the stage. Maria Bayo's Cleopatra catches
all the aspects of the character, from the minx to the unfortunate
prisoner of war. Brian Asawa is one of the few countertenors I've
ever heard whose voice does not sound totally artificial. Lorraine
Hunt and Kathleen Kuhlmann were ideal as son and mother, their duet
being a high point. Only Suzanne Mentzer in the title role
disappointed, her high mezzo unable to cope with the demands of the
role for which, in fact, Kuhlmann would have been ideal. Vassily
Gerelo's Achilla was the other weak element in the cast, unable to
cope with the Handelian coloratura. Ivor Bolton in the pit was
sometimes routine.
|
|

|
|
- In Naxos's continuing survey of the Lutoslawski
orchestral works, Vol. 3 includes Paroles Tissées
(1965)and Les Espaces du Sommeil (1975). The earlier work
was written for Peter Pears and tenor Piotr Kusiewicz is very good
at imposing his own personality on the idiosyncratic Pearsian
writing. Adam Kruszewski has greater difficulty effacing memories of
Fischer-Dieskau in the later work, but once again Naxos offers us a
reasonable alternative for those wishing to expand their musical
horizons (8.553423).
|
|

|
|
- listen to another novelty from Opera Rara,
Rossini's Ricciardo e Zoraide. As with Rosmonda, not
a masterpiece, but fascinating for the way in which the composer
plays with form and convention. A more detailed appreciation will
follow. Naxos is reissuing the Szmanowski recordings previously
available on Marco Polo. Even at top price, these were exceptional
performances, and the disc with the Stabat Mater and some
shorter choral or solo works with orchestra - Veni Creator,
Litanie, Demeter and Penthesilea - offers a
fascinating introduction to an unfamiliar sound world. The Stabat
Mater is the best-known of these pieces and is here given a spacious
- in all senses of the word - reading. All the soloists are beyond
praise, so close are they to the music. I look forward to the coming
releases, but the aural satisfaction already procured is exceptional
(NAXOS 8.553687).
|
|

|
|
- Natalie Dessay gives the third of three concerts
with Patrick Fournillier and the local orchestra. Of the six
scheduled pieces only one has those super-stratospheric notes she
produces with incredible ease, but the artistry with which she
invests the closing scene from Bellini's Sonnambula, the
line she is capable of sustaining, only serve as further
confirmation that her artistry is equal to her vocalism. The Aubade
from Chérubin, or the Berceuse from Lakmé
(sung as an encore), which are unlikely selections for this type of
program, keep the audience spellbound, coughers silenced. And then "Glitter
and be Gay" from Candide, to remind the audience that
she is also an actress and comedienne. Fournillier not only
conducted an orchestra he knows well and has raised to unimagined
heights, he also furnished the few lines of the tenor in an excerpt
from Poulenc's Mamelles de Tirésias.
|
|

|
|
- Total surprise. Manfred Gurlitt's Wozzeck
turns out to be a more than viable stage work and not just a weak
sister to the Berg piece which had its premiere just a few months
earlier. The disparity between the orchestral and vocal writing is
part of its unique atmosphere, while the very different dramaturgic
choices make this a complement rather than a rival. Given that the
Berg is no more than 90 minutes long and the Gurlitt clocks in at 80
minutes, some enterprising management might even consider a double
bill, or else performances on alternate evenings as we are promised
next season in Paris with Fidelio and Leonore. All
credit to conductor Bruno Ferrandis, director Marc Adam and baritone
Vincent le Texier in the title role, and even more to the
beleaguered Opéra de Rouen which is fighting for its life in
one of the politico-cultural squabbles which badly disfigure the
cultural life of France.
|
|

|
|
- Parsifal at the Bastille. Armin Jordan's
four-square beat has the virtue of rapidity, Graham Vick's
production has some bright colors but few ideas, and the cast is
neither inspired nor inspiring. A very long evening.
|
|

|
|
- Listen to Opera Rara's new recording of
Donizetti's Rosmonda d'Inghilterra. Not a masterpiece but
good listening and good Donizetti. Detailed review to follow.
|
|

|
|
- the Chatelet Don Carlos arrives here in
Lyons and I can only ask myself if director Luc Bondy is either
stupid or stubborn in not rethinking some of the particularly
awkward bits of staging that caused titters last year. John Nelson's
conducting is more refined than that of his predecessor, while
Martine Dupuy's Eboli is far more elegantly sung. Stephen Mark Brown
and Victor Torres, replacing Alagna and Hampson, are singers with
voices several sizes too small for their roles, though there is no
denying their enthusiasm. Karita Mattila and José van Dam
repeat their excellent portrayals of Elisabeth and Philippe, warts
and all, but are nonetheless fascinating for the total conviction
and professionalism they both display.
|
|

|
|
- a new production of Jenufa is notable
for the Kostelnicka of Helga Thiede, singing in German, but giving
an unforgettable performance of great subtlety unlike others. Gunnel
Bohmann in the title role is another singer I've never heard before
and she too is impressive, with a pure voice and a simple dignity
which goes well with the part. Of Friedeman Layer's conducting, the
less said the better as he so refines the asperities of the
orchestral writing that the piece almost sounds like Dvorak. A
simple, almost too simple, set is evocative and the straightforward
approach of director Friedrich Meyer-Oertel is greatly appreciated.
|
|

|
|
- La Dame Blanche is a work in need of
special pleading, with a top-notch cast capable of dealing with the
difficult vocal writing and the very dated libretto with much spoken
text. Jean-Louis Pichon's production caught the flavor of the work
but the contributions of Bernard Pisani as both actor and
choreographer were much overdone. Marc Laho's Georges Brown did not
efface memories of more illustrious tenors in his two major airs,
but he did get through the part. Inge Dreisig's Anna was lovely to
look at but too unsure vocally. Dominique Trottein's conducting was
too flaccid. Let us hope the performances at the Opéra-Comique
will be more convincing.
|
|

|
|
- Henze's Prinz von Hombourg is only a few
years younger than Susanna, but a much more accomplished
piece by a composer of the same age with much more operatic
experience. The simple fact that there are musical interludes to
cover the scene changes makes the work seem much shorter than the
far too broken Susanna, even though neither has much more than 100
minutes of music. Jean-Claude Auvray's sensible production captures
the dichotomy of the dream sequences interspersed with reality. François
Leroux in the title role sounds a bit tired but the role is a
killer. Both he and Mari-Ann Häggander as Natalie are so at
home with their roles that the angularity of the vocal writing is
almost forgotten in the ease with which they both sing.
|
|

|
|
- Why am I here, listening to Carlisle Floyd's
first opera, Susannah? And why is it being given its French
premiere only now? The music is closely related to Menotti in its
descent from Puccini, it has some nice tunes, but the melodrama,
especially when the guignol elements are emphasized by director
Philippe Godefroid, is of the sort we find difficult to accept
today. The performers are all working hard, none harder than Regina
Nathan in the title role, who seems not quite to have her heart in
it, unlike conductor Jean-Yves Ossonce. If the choice was to be an
American work of the melodic sort, why not something more recent
like Susa's Liaisons Dangereuses or Corigliano's Ghosts
of Versailles?
|
|

|
|
- Listen to Volume 3 of the Bach cantatas by Ton
Koopman and crew (ERATO 0630-144336-2). It attains the same level of
achievement as the earlier volumes in the series, though one might
welcome some sopranos with more vocal colour.
|
|

|
|
- Listen to Minkowski's new Rameau album and as
always am impressed by the vitality. Véronique Gens is her
usual extraordinary self in the solo cantata Le Berger Fidèle,
while Annick Massis charms us with her major role as Amour in Anacréon.
Only the much too soft-grained baritone of Thierry Félix does
not make the impression it ought as the eponymous hero of the latter
work (ARCHIV 449 211-2).
|
|

|
|
- We go to see the Ballets de Monte Carlo on tour
in Lyons because I am suffering from Balanchine deprivation and they
are giving two of his works on the same program. Stravinsky
Violin Concerto suffers from being played too loudly through the
loudspeakers, while the dancers are struggling too much. They also
have trouble with Who Cares?, to 17 Gershwin
songs, with one of the most beautiful pas de deux to "The
Man I Love". Again, my memories of the first casts help me
through the sometimes inadequate renderings.
|
|

|
|
- Listen to the new Forza from the Kirov
and like much of what I hear. See more detailed review in Operanet's
CD reviews.
|
|

|
|
- Listen to Ying Huang's recital again, thinking I
may have been too harsh, but am once again struck by the lack of
personality and vocal color while appreciating the refusal to force
and a reasonably astute technique.
|
|

|
|
- Things are no better at a performance of
Philippe Manoury's60ème Parallèle, in which
characters who cannot be understood emote while one couldn't care
less. Occasionally the music rises above the pretentiousness of
libretto and staging, but those moments are few and far between.
|
|

|
|
- Attend a performance of Mozart's unwritten
opera, Ombra Felice, a pasticcio put together by the team of
Ursel and Karl Ernst Herrmann, and am relieved to hear that almost
all my colleagues share my feeling of total boredom. How can one
take such gorgeous music as Mozart's concert arias and make such a
non-event of the occasion? I kept feeling that if the pauses were
any more pregnant, they would have to include a delivery room as
part of the rudimentary set.
|
|

|
|
- The second cast of Carmen at the
Bastille was unfortunately unhindered from getting on stage. Roberto
Arias's non-production might almost be subtitled Carmen and the
Three Dwarfs, for the prominent role given to them alongside
three dancers, so that in fact we had three Carmens, Josés
and Escamillos moving around the stage. Arias almost never let the
music speak for itself, seemingly confusing opéra comique
with comic opera, or even music hall. Banal conducting and
insignificant singing by all but Norah Amsellem as Micaela, along
with a blowsy performance in the title role by Béatrice
Uria-Monzon who has already demonstrated that she is capable of
greater subtlety, made for a dull evening.
|
|

|
|
- The 53rd opera (1837), Roberto Devereux,
is to me the most exciting, its conciseness approaching the Verdian
but with vocal writing for Elisabetta which rivals that of Norma
for difficulty. For the first time this weekend we are hearing male
singing which does not need to be tuned out. Giuseppe Sabbatini is a
tenor of taste with exciting high notes when required and his acting
is not limited to three stock gestures. Marianna Nicolesco in the
title role is an object lesson to any aspiring singer of how to make
the most of reduced means, giving a riveting performance, far from
impeccable vocally but inspired. Gloria Scalchi was perhaps too
passive as Sara but sang an exquisite duet with the tenor in half
voice which some idiot in the audience booed.
|
|

|
|
- Maria Stuarda, the 43rd opera (1834), is
perhaps the member of the "Tudor trilogy" which has gained
the most currency, its length far more manageable and the soprano
far more elegiac except for her outburst during the confrontation
with Queen Elizabeth. Maria Pia Piscitelli learned the title role in
three weeks, her unfamiliarity with the work barely perceptible
other than one or two moments when she clearly had difficulty in
pacing herself. The voice is light and for the moment should
probably not sing such a dramatic role except on special occasions.
Her face and body language were always emotionally expressive.
Caroline Sebron as the rival queen has an impressive mezzo-soprano
voice in need of taming: her pitch is not always accurate and she
seems to think that increasing the volume will make us forget her
problems. As with the previous evening, of the males, the less said
the better.
|
|

|
|
- The Monte Carlo Opera is one of the few houses
to have realized that this year is also the 200th anniversary of the
birth of Donizetti, the composer of close to 70 operas, not counting
the numerous revisions - occasionally extreme - of several works,
too few of which grace the repertory of most of our opera houses. In
an interview with John Mordler, director of the Opera (see Operanet
Interview), he told us of his long-range plan, now come to
fruition, to celebrate this important birthday. On this first of
three weekends, the operas were presented in chronological order, so
that we first heard a light version of Anna Bolena, the 30th opera
(from 1830) and that which placed him in the musical forefront of
his day. Giusy Devinu is an affecting performer in the title role
but her vocal means are by no means up to the demands of this
dramatic role created by Pasta. Sonia Ganassi's Seymour was a
welcome return to a lighter mezzo in the role and she easily
encompassed all its demands. Of the remainder of the cast, only Sara
Mingardo as the page Smeton demonstrated a voice and personality
well matched to her role. But where were all the missing pages of
music?
|
|

|
|
- Start listening to Pacini's Saffo on
Marco Polo (8.223883-4) which is a live recording from Wexford. The
sound is not pleasant for starters, while a shouting baritone and
tenor in difficulty take away from one's listening pleasure. Franca
Pedaci in the title role does her best in a role in which the
unforgettable Queen of the pirates has left a memorable souvenir.
And this is music which should be heard occasionally, important in
demonstrating that Verdi did not spring singlehandedly into the
operatic world, with a few hints from Donizetti. Pacini and
Mercadante were also considerable influences.
|
|

|
|
- Listen to Ying Huang, the Butterfly of the film,
who has made a first recital (I first wrote rehearsal) album for
Sony (SK62687) with James Conlon and the London Symphony Orchestra.
One is aware of a pretty but smallish voice, coached by Renata
Scotto as her verbal inflections make clear. But the voice has a
limited range of colors, with limited dynamic range, so that you can
listen to only a few selections at a time.
|
|

|
|
- Entertain two people from opera-l, who are in
Lyons to see the much-travelled Carsen-Christie Orlando. I
haven't gone because two looks at the production in Aix and
Montpellier were more than enough, watching everyone sloshing around
through the water.
Dave
Hall of the Handel page, Hear Handel, and Barbara are good
company and we pass a pleasant evening discussing things operatic,
also sharing our distaste for the production they have just seen.
|
Click here for Diary
Archives January - February
Looking for the best recordings of major works? See
Operanet's 101 Best
Read
Operanet's latest CD review for Recent
Releases
E-mail to the
editor | Back to Operanet
| Back to Culturekiosque
If you value this page, please tell a friend or join our mailing list.
Copyright © 1996 -1999 Culturekiosque
Publications Ltd.
All Rights Reserved